The South African murder of ‘Anni Dewani’ – was it a contract killing?

Anni Dewani murdered

Anni Dewani murdered


Nearly four and a half years ago a 28 year old young Swedish woman Anni Dewani (nee Hindocha) was shot dead late at night in a township near Cape Town. We know exactly who pulled the trigger though, Xolile Mngeni (convicted of her evil carjacking murder, together with accomplices Zola Tongo , and Mziwamadoda Qwabe). A bride tragically killed on her own honeymoon.

Outrage and fury from far & wide has erupted to greet a recent announcement, reportedly from the South African authorities, that Mngeni himself is to be released from jail – set to walk free less than two years into his life sentence BECAUSE he is terminally ill with a brain tumor. Why should he die ‘a free man’?

However, there is another man accused of being directly involved in the murder and indeed of being the person who actually orchestrated it, and arranged it as a contract killing – but he has been neither brought to justice nor acquitted YET. He was arrested on suspicion of conspiracy to murder just weeks after the murder. He is Shrien Dewani, the British husband of the dead woman.

This accused had left the country only a few days after his wife’s killing, and returned home to Bristol in the UK, before he was fingered as a suspect by one of the other men convicted of the horrible crime; Dewanirepeatedly fought & thwarted extradition to answer questions and potential charges in South Africa – because of medically diagnosed ‘depression’.

The South African authorities did though stick doggedly to the task of getting him back there to respond to the accusations made against him, and to get him to throw light on what really happened to that murdered innocent young lady. When he was originally arrested in UK some three weeks after the actual murder, Dewani refused to go back to SA, then six weeks later he first made a mental incapacity claim (stress).

Eventually after nine months Anni Dewani’s own family petitioned the Home Secretary for his extradition; and when granted his lawyers immediately lodged a legal appeal and he was allowed to remain in the UK – eventually for another two years. Mr. Dewani was finally sent to South Africa in early April after a 3 ½ year fight against it.

He has been charged with murder & kidnapping offences, so following-on from Oscar Pistorius, there is now another high profile South African murder trial in the offing.

Dewani is now due to stand trial on five charges at Western Cape High Court in October, but the trial will only go ahead if they decide that he is mentally fit [At the Prosecution’s request the Judge has sent Dewani for a 30-day mental health evaluation (following conflicting reports from two psychiatrists)].

Dewani claims total innocence of any plot of course, and his lawyers assert that the allegations against him are simply plea bargaining lies by the convicted offenders. However, his unbelievable inexcusable ‘abandonment’ of his wife to her fate (even if involuntary), his unprecedented release ‘unharmed’ by the kidnappers at midnight shortly before the killing, and a trickle of leaked evidence of his involvement, together with a seemingly unnatural flight & refusal to go back to Cape Town, the scene of his bride’s kidnapping & shooting, to provide vital information to the police, has dammed him in many eyes and frustrated the poor girl’s family. Yet, the British BBC’s respected television investigatory programme Panorama has reported inconsistencies in evidence and doubts about the strength of the Prosecution evidence and case against Dewani. [It seems unlikely that State forensic evidence will not be challenged by the defence, as it is difficult to ‘correctly’ collect such evidence in countries like South Africa].

Anni Dewani’s family ethnicity is Indian and her parents were Ugandan Asians who immigrated to Sweden, where she was born. She was also educated in the UK at Manchester University and worked as an Engineer for Ericsson the Swedish phone company. She married a fellow Hindu, then her life was prematurely ended two weeks later on 13th November 2010.

Any trial is likely to consider Dewani’s finances, sexual orientation, payments to Tongo [who it is said was offered 15,000 Rand (under £1000)] to organise the killing), his bank transactions, his phone and texts records (as well as those of Anni Dewani), together with any CCTV recordings involving him; also presumably two of the convicted will give evidence against him.

Proper details will only come out if the Dewani trial goes ahead as planned – then we will see where all this is going won’t we?


[The World’s spotlight is on the South African justice system due to two violent killings of young females, first regarding Pistorius’ ongoing trial in Pretoria, and again in Cape Town with Dewani’s (another rich defendant) potential trial. The processes and the verdicts reached will be closely analyzed – of that you can be certain]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.